Arbeitskreis Hannoversche Militärgeschichte -> HOME

 

Mr. Charteris has a good subject in "Butcher" Cumberland, not only on account of the historical and romantic interest of his background, but also by reason of the Duke's baneful reputation.

Mr. Charteris has had the exceptional advantage of studying the Cumberland Papers at Windsor Castle, and it is largely by the aid of hitherto unpublished documents that he is now able to

throw fresh light on a character which has been the subject of so much malevolent criticism. At the same time the volumes deal with the social and political conditions among which Cumberland was called on to play so important a part in the life of the nation. These have been treated by the author with some fulness of detail. Cumberland, in spite of his foreign origin, was remarkably typical of the characteristics of the earlier Georgian period, and an endeavour has been made in these volumes to establish the link between the Duke and the politics, the morals, the aims, and the pursuits of the age in which he lived.
 

Total Evaluation  
Contents  
Science  
Maps  
Illustrations  
Remarks The author makes extensive use of the Cumberland Papers and other unpublished sources and is so able to shed a different light on his subject. Unfortunately he sometimes looses sight of his subject and gives lengthy chapters on the political situation (especially in the second volume); without this the books would be 'very good'.